Homeostasis Preservation

Homepage

29 min read

What is this site?

This site contains the full content of every Quora post from Dewey Gaedcke referencing the concept of “homeostasis preservation” as a fundamental explanatory mechanism for a wide range of human behaviors and psychological phenomena.

Gemini Pro Analysis of the entirety of the content

I. Executive Summary of “Homeostasis Preservation” (HP)

According to Dewey Gaedcke, Homeostasis Preservation (HP) is a deep-seated, evolved, unconscious “program” or “drive” in the human psyche and nervous system. Its primary function is to maintain stability, familiarity, and the “status quo” of one’s identity, worldview, and coping mechanisms. It actively resists any change, even positive or healthy change, if that change is perceived (often unconsciously) as potentially destabilizing. This resistance is a “feature, not a bug,” designed for survival in ancestral environments where rapid deviation from established norms could be dangerous. HP manifests in various ways, including denial, dissociation, rationalization, resistance to therapy, staying in toxic situations, and fear of the unknown. Overcoming or working with HP is crucial for personal growth and healing.

II. Hierarchical Conceptual Tree

  • HOMEEOSTASIS PRESERVATION (HP)
    • A. Nature & Origin
      • 1. Evolved (Genetic) Mandate/Program
        • a. Survival mechanism (ancestral environments)
        • b. Conserving energy
        • c. “Feature, not a bug”
      • 2. Unconscious Drive/Process
        • a. Operates beneath conscious awareness
        • b. Systemic Stabilizer
      • 3. Prioritizes Stability over Comfort/Growth
        • a. Prefers familiar suffering over unfamiliar solutions
      • 4. Synonyms/Related Terms:
        • a. Resistance (to change, to therapy)
        • b. Status Quo preservation
        • c. Fear of destabilization
        • d. “Systemic Stabilizer”
        • e. Sam Harris: “Olympic world champion at remaining EXACTLY WHO WE WERE YESTERDAY”
        • f. Free-Energy Principle (mentioned once)
    • B. Triggers for HP Activation
      • 1. Threat of Destabilizing Change (even positive)
        • a. To identity/sense of self
        • b. To worldview
        • c. To coping mechanisms/familiar patterns
      • 2. Confrontation with Uncomfortable Truths
        • a. About oneself (e.g., failings, responsibility)
        • b. About one’s relationships or family
      • 3. Shame (especially unconscious shame)
      • 4. Fear (of unknown, of vulnerability, of being overwhelmed)
      • 5. Effective Therapy (approaching core issues)
    • C. Mechanisms & Manifestations of HP
      • 1. Cognitive & Emotional Mechanisms
        • a. Denial (of trauma, of problems, of partner’s flaws)
        • b. Dissociation
        • c. Rationalization / Excuse-making
        • d. Motivated Cognition / Emotional Reasoning
        • e. Projection (of own issues onto others)
        • f. Blame (shifting responsibility)
        • g. Cognitive Dissonance reduction (justifying prior decisions)
        • h. Intellectual Sorcery (conveniently exempting abusers from psychological forces)
      • 2. Behavioral Manifestations
        • a. In Therapy:
          • i. Quitting therapy (especially at breakthroughs)
          • ii. Choosing unskilled/ineffective therapists
          • iii. “Peering” (client directing therapy, assuming equal competence)
          • iv. Finding fault with good therapists
          • v. Believing therapy “isn’t working”
          • vi. Resisting therapist’s influence/interventions
        • b. In Relationships:
          • i. Staying in toxic/abusive relationships
          • ii. Repeating patterns (e.g., choosing similar partners)
          • iii. Blaming third parties for affairs
          • iv. Parents sabotaging child’s therapy/growth
          • v. Loyalty to flawed figures (e.g., Trump)
        • c. Self-Perception & Behavior:
          • i. Resisting self-improvement
          • ii. Lack of motivation for treatment (even when aware of illness)
          • iii. Difficulty facing childhood trauma
          • iv. Lying (even after being caught) to avoid more shame
          • v. Rigidity in personality/self-image (e.g., “niceness”)
          • vi. “Identified Patient” phenomenon in families
          • vii. Turning off replies/censorship on Quora (avoiding challenging views)
          • viii. Naively attacking questions or questioners
    • D. Overcoming / Working With HP
      • 1. Awareness & Introspection
        • a. Recognizing HP’s influence
        • b. Studying one’s own unconscious drives, subjectivity, interpretive framework
        • c. Identifying “as-if beliefs”
      • 2. Therapeutic Approaches
        • a. Good Therapy (skilled therapists)
          • i. Creating safety
          • ii. Pacing (not overwhelming the client)
          • iii. Retraining the nervous system
          • iv. Helping acquire alternative strategies/resources/competencies (“backfilling”)
          • v. Facilitating NEW experiences (experiential work)
          • vi. Honoring and working with resistance (psychological non-violence)
        • b. Somatic Therapies (highly recommended by Dewey)
          • i. Hakomi
          • ii. Somatic Experiencing (SE)
        • c. Mindfulness
        • d. Psychedelics (Ketamine, Psilocybin - mentioned cautiously)
        • e. Recognizing therapist skill vs. own HP-driven judgment
      • 3. Personal Practices
        • a. Tolerating discomfort / Facing fear
        • b. Experimenting with new behaviors (stepping outside comfort zone)
        • c. Self-forgiveness
        • d. Taking responsibility for one’s own suffering/healing
        • e. Testing models of reality (e.g., on Quora, facing criticism)
    • E. Concepts Interacting with HP
      • 1. Shame (unconscious shame as a driver & something HP protects from)
      • 2. Trauma (especially childhood trauma; HP makes it hard to face)
      • 3. Unconscious Mind (where HP resides and operates)
      • 4. Identity & Worldview (what HP seeks to protect)
      • 5. Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD)
        • a. NPDs resist change due to HP & rewards
        • b. Partners of NPDs stay due to their own HP, codependence, self-image
      • 6. Codependence (as a strategy HP might protect)
      • 7. Self-Esteem (HP can protect flawed esteem-gathering strategies)
      • 8. Free Will (HP challenges the sense of free will when its influence is recognized)
      • 9. Subjectivity & Interpretive Framework (HP distorts these to maintain stability)

III. Semantic Map (Simplified Textual Representation)

(Central Node: Homeostasis Preservation)

  • Is an: Evolved, Unconscious Drive, Survival Mechanism, Resistance to Change
  • Aims to: Preserve Stability, Status Quo, Identity, Worldview, Conserve Energy
  • Triggered by: Threat of Change, Shame, Fear, Uncomfortable Truths, Effective Therapy
  • Manifests as (Cognitive/Emotional): Denial, Dissociation, Rationalization, Projection, Blame, Motivated Cognition
  • Manifests as (Behavioral):
    • In Therapy: Quitting, Choosing Bad Therapists, Client “Peering”, Sabotaging Progress
    • In Relationships: Staying Toxic, Repeating Patterns, Scapegoating, Parental Sabotage
    • General: Resisting Self-Help, Lying, Rigidity, “Identified Patient”
  • Counteracted/Managed by:
    • Self-Awareness, Introspection
    • Skilled Therapy (Somatic: Hakomi, SE; Mindfulness)
    • Facing Discomfort, Building New Resources
    • Taking Responsibility
  • Interacts with:
    • Shame (fuels & is protected by HP)
    • Trauma (HP makes facing it hard)
    • Unconscious Mind (location of HP)
    • NPD (both NPD and partner affected by HP)
    • Codependence
    • Self-Esteem
    • Free Will (perception of)

IV. List of Tags / Keywords

Homeostasis Preservation, Resistance, Status Quo, Unconscious Mind, Evolution, Survival, Change, Destabilization, Fear, Shame, Denial, Dissociation, Rationalization, Projection, Blame, Therapy, Psychotherapy, Somatic Therapy, Hakomi, Somatic Experiencing, Mindfulness, Trauma, Childhood Trauma, NPD, Narcissism, Codependence, Relationships, Family Systems, Parenting, Self-Esteem, Identity, Worldview, Subjectivity, Interpretive Framework, Cognitive Distortions, Emotional Reasoning, Self-Sabotage, Healing, Personal Growth, Accountability, Jordan Peterson (critique of), Free Will, Psychological Non-Violence, “Peering”, “Identified Patient”.

V. Potential Concept Pages (for Hyperlinking within Answers)

If these answers were part of a digital system, the following “concept pages” could be created and linked whenever the term appears.

  1. Homeostasis Preservation (HP)

    • Definition: Dewey’s core concept – an evolved, unconscious drive to maintain stability and resist destabilizing change to identity, worldview, or coping mechanisms. It’s a “feature, not a bug” for survival.
    • Key Answers: [Why do cheaters continue to lie…], [Why are some people so afraid of facing childhood trauma?], [Do you ever feel like therapy doesn’t work?], etc. (virtually all answers).
    • Related Concepts: Resistance, Status Quo, Unconscious Mind, Evolution, Denial, Shame.

  2. Unconscious Mind

    • Definition: The part of the mind operating outside conscious awareness, housing deep-seated drives (like HP), memories, and automatic processes. It significantly influences behavior and perception.
    • Key Answers: [Why do cheaters continue to lie…], [Why can’t people stop blaming their toxic habits…], [What is your greatest weakness as a psychologist…].
    • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Shame, Trauma, Automatic Behaviors.

  3. Shame (especially Unconscious Shame)

    • Definition: A debilitating emotion often buried in the unconscious. HP is strongly activated to avoid triggering or exposing unconscious shame. Admitting wrongdoing brightens the “light” on this shame.
    • Key Answers: [Why do cheaters continue to lie…], [Why are some people so afraid of facing childhood trauma?], [How can you convince someone they are abusive…].
    • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Denial, Lying, Resistance to Change.

  4. Denial

    • Definition: An unconscious defense mechanism, a “feature, not a bug,” driven by HP to suppress awareness of painful or destabilizing information, preserving psychological equilibrium.
    • Key Answers: [Why do cheaters continue to lie…], [How does denial frequently arise in the context of narcissism?], [Is it possible for someone to be in denial about experiencing childhood trauma?].
    • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Unconscious Mind, Shame, Trauma.

  5. Therapy (and its Challenges)

    • Definition: A process of retraining the nervous system and gaining self-awareness. Good therapy must involve some discomfort and destabilization to be effective, which often triggers HP.
    • Sub-topics: Resistance in therapy, Quitting therapy, Choosing therapists, Somatic vs. Talk therapy, Therapist skill.
    • Key Answers: [Do you ever feel like therapy doesn’t work?], [Doesn’t the “therapeutic relationship”…], [Is it normal to reach a point in therapy…], [Why don’t people believe in therapy?].
    • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Somatic Therapy, Resistance, Unconscious Mind.

  6. Somatic Therapy (Hakomi, Somatic Experiencing)

    • Definition: Body-based psychotherapies highly recommended by Dewey for their effectiveness in working with non-verbal, limbic system-based trauma and patterns, often bypassing cognitive resistance.
    • Key Answers: [I’ve been in therapy for 10 years…], [Why don’t people believe in therapy?], [What is the best approach for emotional abuse, trauma and PTSD?].
    • Related Concepts: Therapy, Trauma, Unconscious Mind, Homeostasis Preservation (effective in working with it).

  7. Trauma (especially Childhood Trauma)

    • Definition: Deeply impactful negative experiences, often from childhood, that shape personality, coping mechanisms, and unconscious beliefs. HP makes facing trauma difficult.
    • Key Answers: [Why are some people so afraid of facing childhood trauma?], [Is it possible for someone to be their own therapist and heal from childhood trauma…], [Adult Why does it take a lifetime to overcome the effects of child abuse…].
    • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Shame, Denial, Somatic Therapy, Unconscious Mind.

  8. Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) & Relationships

    • Definition: Discussion of NPD often revolves around why NPD individuals resist change (HP, rewards) and why their partners stay (HP, codependence, self-image linked to being “good” or “loyal”).
    • Key Answers: [How does denial frequently arise in the context of narcissism?], [Can a narcissist ever actually change…], [How does a narcissist secretly manipulate their partner?].
    • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Shame, Denial, Codependence, Self-Esteem.

  9. Subjectivity / Interpretive Framework / Motivated Cognition

    • Definition: The idea that our perception of reality is shaped by our past experiences, unconscious beliefs, and emotional agendas, often in service of HP. We see what confirms our existing views.
    • Key Answers: [How do you understand human behavior?], [Would you pursue the truth even if…], [Is the compulsion to be right…], [Why won’t my therapist validate my racial trauma?].
    • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Unconscious Mind, Denial, Emotional Reasoning.

  10. Accountability & Responsibility

    • Definition: Dewey often emphasizes that while individuals are not to blame for unconscious patterns (like HP), they are responsible for taking steps to understand and change them for a better future. HP often drives avoidance of this responsibility.
    • Key Answers: [Would you feel disrespected if your husband…stared at another woman’s butt…], [Why is it that when people get cheated on…they most likely blame the third person?], [How often do highly empathetic parents cause highly narcissistic children?].
    • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Blame, Shame, Personal Growth.

VI. Overall Themes & Dewey Gaedcke’s Stance

  • Centrality of the Unconscious: The unconscious mind and its evolved drives (especially HP) are paramount in explaining human behavior.
  • Evolutionary Psychology Perspective: Many psychological traits are framed as adaptive (or once-adaptive) survival mechanisms.
  • Critique of Surface-Level Explanations: Dewey often pushes past simplistic or purely cognitive explanations to deeper, systemic, and often uncomfortable truths about why people behave as they do.
  • Emphasis on Experiential & Somatic Healing: Strong preference for therapies that engage the body and emotions directly (Hakomi, SE) over purely talk-based or cognitive approaches.
  • Challenge to Client’s Perception of Therapy: Clients often misjudge therapy’s effectiveness due to HP-driven resistance when real change is near.
  • Personal Responsibility (without Blame): While not blaming individuals for unconscious patterns, he stresses the importance of self-awareness and taking action to change.
  • Skepticism of “Easy” Change: Real change is difficult, slow, and often uncomfortable precisely because of HP.
  • The “Feature, Not a Bug” Principle: Defense mechanisms like denial are seen as integral parts of the psyche’s design for stability, not mere pathologies.

Grok Analysis

1. Hierarchical Conceptual Tree

The hierarchical tree organizes the concepts into a structured format, with Homeostasis Preservation as the central concept. The branches represent different contexts or applications where this concept plays a key role.

  • Homeostasis Preservation
    • Definition: The unconscious drive to maintain stability in one’s identity, worldview, and psychological state, resisting change even when it might be beneficial.
    • Branches:
      1. Therapy and Personal Growth
        • Unconscious resistance to change in therapy
        • Fear of facing trauma
        • Difficulty in changing habits or behaviors
        • Rationalizations for quitting therapy (e.g., “it’s not working,” “too expensive,” “therapist is incompetent”)
        • Desire to switch to new healing modalities to avoid deeper work
      2. Interpersonal Relationships
        • Blaming others instead of taking responsibility (e.g., blaming the third party in infidelity)
        • Loyalty to problematic figures or beliefs (e.g., political loyalty, staying with abusive partners)
        • Codependency (e.g., identity tied to being “nice” or supportive)
        • Narcissism (e.g., denial and manipulation to preserve self-image)
        • Projection and scapegoating (e.g., parents blaming children for family issues)
      3. Emotional and Psychological Mechanisms
        • Denial and dissociation as tools to avoid destabilization
        • Shame and avoidance of overwhelming emotions
        • Victim mentality as a way to preserve identity
        • Reactions to being proven wrong (e.g., anger, frustration)
        • Fear of healing trauma due to potential destabilization
      4. Social and Cultural Phenomena
        • Political tribalism and loyalty (e.g., Trump followers)
        • Resistance to new ideas or approaches (e.g., holistic healing methods)
        • Social behaviors like refusing to wear masks (identity and image management over empathy)
        • Virtue signaling and moral outrage to boost self-esteem

2. Semantic Map

The semantic map visually represents the relationships between key concepts, showing how Homeostasis Preservation influences various behaviors and phenomena.

  • Homeostasis Preservation
    • Leads to → Resistance to Change
      • Manifests as → Denial, Dissociation, Rationalization
      • Affects → Therapy Outcomes (e.g., quitting therapy, finding faults in therapists)
      • Influences → Relationships (e.g., blaming others, loyalty to problematic figures)
    • Connected to → Identity and Worldview Stability
      • Drives → Projection and Scapegoating (e.g., parents blaming children)
      • Reinforces → Codependency and Narcissism
    • Triggers → Emotional Reactions
      • Such as → Fear of Destabilization, Shame, Anger when Proven Wrong
    • Impacts → Social Behaviors
      • Leads to → Tribalism, Resistance to New Ideas, Victim Mentality

This map illustrates how homeostasis preservation is the underlying mechanism driving many psychological and social behaviors discussed in the answers.

3. List of Tags or Concept Pages

Below is a list of key terms and concepts that appear throughout the answers. These can be used as tags or linked to concept pages for deeper exploration:

  • Homeostasis Preservation
  • Unconscious Resistance
  • Denial
  • Dissociation
  • Shame
  • Trauma
  • Therapy
  • Change
  • Identity
  • Worldview
  • Stability
  • Fear of Destabilization
  • Rationalization
  • Projection
  • Blaming
  • Responsibility
  • Codependency
  • Narcissism
  • Loyalty
  • Tribalism
  • Cognitive Dissonance
  • Emotional Reasoning
  • Motivated Cognition
  • Victim Mentality
  • Therapeutic Relationship
  • Resistance in Therapy
  • Self-Sabotage
  • Identity Entanglement
  • Systemic Stabilizer
  • Repetition Compulsion

Each of these tags can be linked to relevant sections in the answers where they are discussed.

4. Concept Pages for Homeostasis Preservation

Below is a collection of concept pages exploring key psychological concepts related to homeostasis preservation. Each page provides a definition, examples, and connections to other relevant ideas, organized alphabetically for easy navigation.

Blaming

  • Definition: Assigning responsibility for a problem to someone else, often as a way to preserve one’s own identity and avoid change.
  • Examples:
    • Blaming the third party in infidelity (“Why is it that when people get cheated on, they most likely blame the third person?”).
    • Parents blaming children for family issues (“Did your parents take you to see counselors, instead of pointing the finger at themselves?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Projection, Responsibility.

Change

  • Definition: The process of becoming different, often resisted due to the drive for homeostasis preservation.
  • Examples:
    • Resistance to change in therapy (“Do you ever feel like therapy doesn’t work?”).
    • Fear of change in relationships (“What is wrong with me? My relationship with my parents is so emotionally abusive, but I feel like I can’t leave.”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Unconscious Resistance, Stability.

Codependency

  • Definition: A behavioral condition where individuals prioritize others’ needs over their own, often as a strategy to preserve identity and homeostasis.
  • Examples:
    • Identity tied to being supportive (“How or why does somebody become codependent?”).
    • Difficulty in setting boundaries (“How or why does somebody become codependent?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Identity, Narcissism.

Cognitive Dissonance

  • Definition: The mental discomfort experienced when holding contradictory beliefs, often resolved by altering beliefs or behaviors to preserve homeostasis.
  • Examples:
    • Loyalty to a figure despite evidence (“Could Trump followers be considered a cult?”).
    • Justifying quitting therapy (“Do you ever feel like therapy doesn’t work?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Rationalization, Denial.

Denial

  • Definition: A defense mechanism that avoids uncomfortable truths or emotions to preserve psychological stability.
  • Examples:
    • Parents denying their role in family issues (“Did your parents take you to see counselors, instead of pointing the finger at themselves?”).
    • Refusing to acknowledge relationship problems (“Why is it that when people get cheated on, they most likely blame the third person?”).
    • Dismissing therapy to avoid personal issues (“Why are most parents, even good ones, in denial about their failings?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Shame, Projection, Blaming.

Dissociation

  • Definition: A psychological process of disconnecting from thoughts, feelings, or identity, often to preserve homeostasis by avoiding overwhelming experiences.
  • Examples:
    • Dissociation during trauma (“Why do people disassociate?”).
    • Avoiding destabilization in therapy (“Why do people disassociate?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Trauma, Unconscious Resistance.

Emotional Reasoning

  • Definition: A cognitive distortion where emotions are taken as evidence of truth, often to preserve homeostasis.
  • Examples:
    • Feeling therapy isn’t working (“Do you ever feel like therapy doesn’t work?”).
    • Anger when proven wrong (“In psychology, why do people sometimes respond with anger or frustration to being proven wrong?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Cognitive Dissonance, Motivated Cognition.

Fear of Destabilization

  • Definition: Anxiety about losing stability in identity or worldview, driven by homeostasis preservation.
  • Examples:
    • Fear of healing trauma (“Why am I scared to heal my trauma?”).
    • Resistance to therapy nearing change (“Is it normal to feel like quitting therapy every so often?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Stability, Change.

Homeostasis Preservation

  • Definition: The unconscious drive to maintain stability in identity, worldview, and psychological state, resisting beneficial change.
  • Examples:
    • Resistance to therapy (“Do you ever feel like therapy doesn’t work?”).
    • Fear of facing trauma (“Why are some people so afraid of facing childhood trauma?”).
    • Blaming others to avoid responsibility (“Why is it that when people get cheated on, they most likely blame the third person?”).
    • Loyalty despite evidence (“Could Trump followers be considered a cult?”).
  • Related Concepts: Unconscious Resistance, Denial, Dissociation, Shame, Identity, Worldview, Stability, Fear of Destabilization.

Identity

  • Definition: The sense of self, preserved through homeostasis preservation, resisting changes that threaten it.
  • Examples:
    • Identity tied to codependency (“How or why does somebody become codependent?”).
    • Preserving identity in narcissism (“How does denial frequently arise in the context of narcissism?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Worldview, Stability.

Identity Entanglement

  • Definition: When one’s sense of self is deeply tied to behaviors or roles, making change difficult due to homeostasis preservation.
  • Examples:
    • Codependency (“How or why does somebody become codependent?”).
    • Narcissism (“How does denial frequently arise in the context of narcissism?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Identity, Codependency, Narcissism.

Loyalty

  • Definition: Strong support or allegiance, maintained despite contrary evidence to preserve homeostasis.
  • Examples:
    • Loyalty to political figures (“Could Trump followers be considered a cult?”).
    • Staying in abusive relationships (“What is wrong with me? My relationship with my parents is so emotionally abusive, but I feel like I can’t leave.”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Identity, Worldview.

Motivated Cognition

  • Definition: The unconscious tendency to process information to support preexisting beliefs, driven by homeostasis preservation.
  • Examples:
    • Defending one’s worldview (“Why do so many people want to be seen to be right, and make others wrong?”).
    • Loyalty to figures (“Could Trump followers be considered a cult?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Cognitive Dissonance, Emotional Reasoning.

Narcissism

  • Definition: A personality trait marked by self-importance and a need for admiration, using denial and manipulation to preserve self-image.
  • Examples:
    • Denial in narcissism (“How does denial frequently arise in the context of narcissism?”).
    • Narcissistic parenting (“How often do highly empathetic parents cause highly narcissistic children?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Denial, Identity Entanglement.

Projection

  • Definition: Attributing one’s own unacceptable thoughts or feelings to others to preserve homeostasis.
  • Examples:
    • Parents projecting onto children (“Did your parents take you to see counselors, instead of pointing the finger at themselves?”).
    • Blaming the third party in infidelity (“Why is it that when people get cheated on, they most likely blame the third person?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Denial, Blaming.

Rationalization

  • Definition: Creating logical justifications for behaviors driven by unconscious motives, often to preserve homeostasis.
  • Examples:
    • Justifying quitting therapy (“Do you ever feel like therapy doesn’t work?”).
    • Blaming others to avoid responsibility (“Why is it that when people get cheated on, they most likely blame the third person?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Denial, Unconscious Resistance.

Repetition Compulsion

  • Definition: The unconscious tendency to repeat past behaviors or experiences, often traumatic, to preserve homeostasis.
  • Examples:
    • Staying in abusive relationships (“What is wrong with me? My relationship with my parents is so emotionally abusive, but I feel like I can’t leave.”).
    • Revisiting trauma (“What is your greatest weakness as a psychologist and how do you handle it?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Trauma, Unconscious Resistance.

Resistance in Therapy

  • Definition: Unconscious opposition to the therapeutic process, driven by homeostasis preservation.
  • Examples:
    • Wanting to quit therapy (“Is it normal to feel like quitting therapy every so often?”).
    • Feeling therapy isn’t working (“Do you ever feel like therapy doesn’t work?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Unconscious Resistance, Change.

Responsibility

  • Definition: Being accountable for one’s actions, often avoided through blaming or denial to preserve homeostasis.
  • Examples:
    • Avoiding responsibility in relationships (“Why is it that when people get cheated on, they most likely blame the third person?”).
    • Parents evading family dynamics responsibility (“Did your parents take you to see counselors, instead of pointing the finger at themselves?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Blaming, Denial.

Self-Sabotage

  • Definition: Behaviors or thoughts undermining one’s success, unconsciously driven by homeostasis preservation.
  • Examples:
    • Quitting therapy prematurely (“Is it normal to feel like quitting therapy every so often?”).
    • Avoiding relationship change (“What is wrong with me? My relationship with my parents is so emotionally abusive, but I feel like I can’t leave.”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Unconscious Resistance, Fear of Destabilization.

Shame

  • Definition: A painful emotion from guilt or inadequacy, motivating behaviors to avoid further shame and preserve homeostasis.
  • Examples:
    • Cheaters lying to avoid shame (“Why do cheaters continue to lie even after they have been caught?”).
    • Shame blocking trauma confrontation (“Why are some people so afraid of facing childhood trauma?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Denial, Unconscious Resistance.

Stability

  • Definition: The state of being stable, maintained through homeostasis preservation, often at the expense of growth.
  • Examples:
    • Resisting therapy to maintain stability (“Is it normal to reach a point in therapy where you no longer want to talk or open up?”).
    • Staying in abusive relationships (“What is wrong with me? My relationship with my parents is so emotionally abusive, but I feel like I can’t leave.”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Change, Fear of Destabilization.

Systemic Stabilizer

  • Definition: A metaphorical unconscious mechanism preserving homeostasis by resisting destabilizing changes.
  • Examples:
    • Resistance to therapy (“Is it normal to feel like quitting therapy every so often?”).
    • Fear of healing trauma (“Why am I scared to heal my trauma?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Unconscious Resistance, Stability.

Therapeutic Relationship

  • Definition: The professional bond between therapist and client, influenced by resistance due to homeostasis preservation.
  • Examples:
    • Feeling like quitting therapy (“Is it normal to feel like quitting therapy every so often?”).
    • Finding faults in the therapist (“Is it normal to try and find faults in my therapist?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Unconscious Resistance, Resistance in Therapy.

Trauma

  • Definition: A distressing experience with lasting psychological effects, resisted due to homeostasis preservation.
  • Examples:
    • Fear of facing childhood trauma (“Why are some people so afraid of facing childhood trauma?”).
    • Trauma as a therapy barrier (“Why am I scared to heal my trauma?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Dissociation, Unconscious Resistance.

Tribalism

  • Definition: Strong loyalty to one’s group, preserved through homeostasis preservation.
  • Examples:
    • Political tribalism (“Could Trump followers be considered a cult?”).
    • Resistance to new ideas (“Why are so many people on Quora opposed to a social norm that tolerates the civil, free exchange of ideas?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Loyalty, Identity.

Unconscious Resistance

  • Definition: A mechanism driven by homeostasis preservation that prevents beneficial change.
  • Examples:
    • Quitting therapy near growth (“Is it normal to feel like quitting therapy every so often?”).
    • Avoiding therapy due to destabilization fears (“Why don’t people believe in therapy?”).
    • Rationalizing therapy’s failure (“Do you ever feel like therapy doesn’t work?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Denial, Rationalization, Fear of Destabilization.

Victim Mentality

  • Definition: Perceiving oneself as a victim to preserve identity and avoid responsibility.
  • Examples:
    • Wanting victim recognition (“Why do I want people to know that I’m a victim?”).
    • Blaming others for problems (“Why is it that when people get cheated on, they most likely blame the third person?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Blaming, Responsibility.

Worldview

  • Definition: A comprehensive perspective on the world, preserved through homeostasis preservation, resisting challenging information.
  • Examples:
    • Resisting new ideas (“Why are so many people on Quora opposed to a social norm that tolerates the civil, free exchange of ideas?”).
    • Loyalty despite evidence (“Could Trump followers be considered a cult?”).
  • Related Concepts: Homeostasis Preservation, Identity, Stability.

This collection provides a thorough exploration of concepts tied to homeostasis preservation, illustrating their roles in human behavior, therapy, and relationships.

Claude Analysis

Core Definition

Homeostasis preservation is described as a powerful unconscious drive built into humans by evolution that resists destabilizing change, even when that change would be positive. It’s characterized as “a program in your unconscious, installed there by evolution, [that] tries to keep things stable and familiar” - essentially a resistance to change.

Key Characteristics of Homeostasis Preservation

  1. Evolutionary Origin According to Dewey, this is not a bug but a feature of human psychology, designed by evolution for survival purposes. When our ancestors changed in sudden ways, they became less fit for their environment and more emotionally volatile, reducing their chances of survival.

  2. Unconscious Operation It operates below conscious awareness, often making people unaware of their own resistance to change.

  3. Primary Function To maintain stability of identity, worldview, and coping strategies - preserving the “status quo” and what is familiar.

  4. Relationship to Other Psychological Mechanisms Homeostasis preservation powers mechanisms like denial, dissociation, repression, rationalization, and other defense mechanisms.

Manifestations in Behavior and Psychology

1. Therapy Resistance

People often quit therapy right when major breakthroughs are imminent because homeostasis preservation activates to prevent destabilizing change. This manifests as finding excuses to quit therapy, convincing oneself therapy isn’t working, or finding fault with the therapist.

2. Relationship Patterns

Explains why people stay in or return to toxic relationships - the unconscious prefers the familiar pain over unfamiliar change.

3. Cognitive Distortions

Drives denial, rationalization, and emotional reasoning that preserves existing worldviews despite contradictory evidence.

4. Addiction and Recovery Challenges

Makes recovery difficult as the established patterns and identity are threatened by sobriety.

5. Family Systems Dynamics

Family members unconsciously resist change in other members because it destabilizes the family system, even when the change would be positive.

6. Political and Social Beliefs

Explains resistance to information that contradicts one’s political worldview or societal changes that threaten established identities.

Contexts Where Homeostasis Preservation Appears

1. Mental Health Treatment

Resistance to therapy, difficulty finding or staying with a good therapist, feeling therapy isn’t working, questioning the therapist’s competence.

2. Abuse and Trauma Recovery

Difficulty leaving abusive relationships, rationalizing partner behavior, blaming third parties rather than partners.

3. Personal Change and Growth

Resistance to new habits, discomfort with self-improvement practices, self-sabotage.

4. Identity Challenges

Resistance to information that contradicts core beliefs about oneself.

5. Parenting and Child Development

Parents resisting their children’s growth that threatens family stability, identified patient patterns.

6. Social and Political Discourse

Resistance to challenging conversations, turning off comments on controversial posts, blocking or avoiding people with challenging views.

Overcoming Homeostasis Preservation

1. Therapeutic Approaches

Somatic therapies (Hakomi, Somatic Experiencing) are recommended as they work with the non-verbal nervous system where these patterns are stored.

2. Mindfulness and Awareness

Noticing resistance when it arises, developing curiosity about one’s reactions.

3. Gradual Exposure to Change

Starting with small changes to build tolerance for unfamiliarity.

4. Building Internal Resources

Developing alternative strategies for meeting needs before abandoning old patterns.

5. Working with Skilled Practitioners

Finding therapists who understand homeostasis preservation and can work with it skillfully.

6. Persistence Through Discomfort

Recognizing that discomfort during change is normal and not necessarily a sign to stop.

1. Unconscious Mind Functioning

How the unconscious prioritizes and processes information.

2. Defense Mechanisms

Denial, dissociation, repression, and rationalization as tools of homeostasis preservation.

3. Identity Formation and Maintenance

How identities are formed, maintained, and defended.

4. Trauma Responses

How trauma creates rigid patterns that resist change.

5. Codependence and Personality Strategies

How personality strategies like codependence maintain homeostasis.

6. Family Systems Theory

How families maintain equilibrium even at the cost of individual health.

Hierarchical Concept Tree

HOMEOSTASIS PRESERVATION
├── Fundamental Characteristics
│   ├── Evolutionary purpose
│   ├── Unconscious operation
│   ├── Status quo maintenance
│   └── Resistance to destabilization
│
├── Psychological Mechanisms
│   ├── Denial
│   ├── Dissociation
│   ├── Rationalization
│   ├── Projection
│   ├── Emotional reasoning
│   └── Cognitive distortions
│
├── Manifestations
│   ├── Therapy Resistance
│   │   ├── Finding fault with therapist
│   │   ├── Feeling therapy isn't working
│   │   ├── Quitting at breakthrough points
│   │   └── Self-sabotage of treatment
│   │
│   ├── Relationship Patterns
│   │   ├── Staying in toxic relationships
│   │   ├── Returning to familiar partners
│   │   ├── Blaming third parties
│   │   └── Stockholm syndrome
│   │
│   ├── Identity Protection
│   │   ├── Defending worldviews
│   │   ├── Resistance to contradictory evidence
│   │   ├── Political/ideological rigidity
│   │   └── Self-image preservation
│   │
│   ├── Family Systems
│   │   ├── Identified patient dynamics
│   │   ├── Resistance to child's growth
│   │   ├── Enabling behaviors
│   │   └── Systemic equilibrium
│   │
│   └── Social Interaction
│       ├── Echo chambers
│       ├── Avoiding challenging conversations
│       ├── Censoring opposing views
│       └── Information avoidance
│
├── Contexts & Applications
│   ├── Mental Health Treatment
│   ├── Personal Growth
│   ├── Trauma Recovery
│   ├── Addiction Recovery
│   ├── Parenting
│   ├── Political Discourse
│   └── Social Change
│
└── Overcoming Strategies
    ├── Therapeutic Approaches
    │   ├── Somatic therapies
    │   ├── Hakomi
    │   ├── Mindfulness
    │   └── Skilled practitioner guidance
    │
    ├── Personal Practices
    │   ├── Gradual exposure to change
    │   ├── Building alternative resources
    │   ├── Tolerating discomfort
    │   └── Curiosity about resistance
    │
    └── Systemic Approaches
        ├── Family therapy
        ├── Group support
        ├── Environmental changes
        └── Building safety for change

Semantic Network Map

                                     ┌─────────────────┐
                                     │    Evolution    │
                                     └────────┬────────┘
                                              │
                                              ▼
               ┌───────────────┐    ┌─────────────────┐    ┌───────────────┐
               │  Unconscious  │◄───┤   HOMEOSTASIS   ├───►│   Stability   │
               │    Process    │    │  PRESERVATION   │    │  Maintenance  │
               └───────┬───────┘    └────────┬────────┘    └───────────────┘
                       │                     │
         ┌─────────────┴─────────┐          │          ┌─────────────────────┐
         ▼                       ▼          │          ▼                     ▼
┌─────────────────┐     ┌─────────────────┐ │ ┌─────────────────┐   ┌─────────────────┐
│     Denial      │     │  Dissociation   │ │ │ Rationalization │   │    Projection   │
└─────────────────┘     └─────────────────┘ │ └─────────────────┘   └─────────────────┘
                                            │
          ┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
          │                                                          │
          ▼                                                          ▼
┌─────────────────────┐                                  ┌─────────────────────────┐
│ Therapy Resistance  │                                  │ Relationship Patterns   │
└──────────┬──────────┘                                  └───────────┬─────────────┘
           │                                                         │
           ▼                                                         ▼
┌─────────────────────┐                                  ┌─────────────────────────┐
│  Quitting Therapy   │                                  │   Staying with Toxic    │
│ When Close to Change│                                  │        Partners         │
└─────────────────────┘                                  └─────────────────────────┘

          ┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
          │                     HOMEOSTASIS                          │
          │                     PRESERVATION                         │
          └──────────────────────────┬───────────────────────────────┘
                                     │
          ┌──────────────────────────┴───────────────────────────────┐
          ▼                                                          ▼
┌─────────────────────┐                                  ┌─────────────────────────┐
│   Family Systems    │                                  │   Identity Protection   │
└──────────┬──────────┘                                  └───────────┬─────────────┘
           │                                                         │
           ▼                                                         ▼
┌─────────────────────┐                                  ┌─────────────────────────┐
│ Resistance to Child │                                  │ Defending Worldviews &  │
│      Growth         │                                  │      Belief Systems     │
└─────────────────────┘                                  └─────────────────────────┘

                           ┌─────────────────┐
                           │  Overcoming     │
                           │  Homeostasis    │
                           │  Preservation   │
                           └────────┬────────┘
                                    │
          ┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
          ▼                                                          ▼
┌─────────────────────┐                                  ┌─────────────────────────┐
│ Somatic Therapies   │                                  │   Building Alternative  │
│ (Hakomi, SE)        │                                  │       Resources         │
└─────────────────────┘                                  └─────────────────────────┘

Tag/Category System

If organizing Dewey’s content into a knowledge base, these would be the key topic tags:

  1. HomeostasisPreservation - Core concept and definition
  2. EvolutionaryPsychology - Evolutionary origins and purpose
  3. TherapyResistance - Resistance to therapeutic change
  4. DefenseMechanisms - Related psychological defenses
  5. RelationshipPatterns - How it affects relationship choices
  6. FamilySystems - Family dynamics and equilibrium
  7. Denial - Connection to denial and repression
  8. IdentityProtection - Self-image and worldview defense
  9. CognitiveDistortions - Related thinking patterns
  10. SomaticTherapy - Somatic approaches to change
  11. UnconsciousMind - Unconscious operations and drivers
  12. ChangeTolerance - Building capacity for change
  13. TraumaRecovery - Application to healing trauma
  14. PoliticalPsychology - Effects on political beliefs
  15. SystemicStability - Broader systems application
  16. MindfulAwareness - Role of awareness in change
  17. PersonalGrowthObstacles - Barriers to development
  18. EmotionalReasoning - Connection to emotional thinking
  19. PsychologicalRigidity - Inflexibility and resistance
  20. AdaptiveResponses - Positive aspects and adaptivity

Conceptual Relationships and Distinctions

Dewey makes important distinctions between homeostasis preservation as a natural, evolutionary process versus pathology. He emphasizes it’s “a feature, not a bug” of human psychology. This evolutionary drive once helped humans survive by maintaining stability, but in modern contexts, it can prevent necessary adaptation and growth.

He also distinguishes between unconscious resistance (homeostasis preservation) and conscious resistance (deliberate opposition), emphasizing that most self-sabotaging behaviors are driven by the former, not the latter.

A critical insight in his framework is the relationship between homeostasis preservation and resources: the unconscious will allow change only when it perceives sufficient alternative resources are available to meet needs once established patterns change.

Practical Applications and Interventions

The conceptual framework suggests several practical interventions:

  1. Resource-First Approach: Build alternative ways of meeting needs before attempting to dismantle old coping strategies.

  2. Somatic Focus: Work with the body and nervous system rather than just cognitive approaches.

  3. Graduated Exposure: Start with small changes to build tolerance for unfamiliarity.

  4. Mindful Observation: Notice resistance when it arises without judgment.

  5. Therapeutic Contracts: Agreement to discuss quitting therapy before acting on the impulse.

  6. Skilled Guidance: Working with practitioners who understand homeostasis preservation.

Cross-Disciplinary Connections

Dewey’s concept connects to several established theoretical frameworks:

  1. Systems Theory: Parallels with how systems maintain equilibrium

  2. Family Systems Therapy: The identified patient as system stabilizer

  3. Psychodynamic Theory: Unconscious resistance and defense mechanisms

  4. Evolutionary Psychology: Adaptive value of stability

  5. Somatic Psychology: Body-based approaches to change

  6. Cognitive Neuroscience: Brain processes that maintain stability

Summary

Homeostasis preservation emerges from Dewey Gaedcke’s writings as a fundamental organizing principle of human psychology with far-reaching implications. It explains resistance to beneficial change across domains from personal therapy to social movements. His framework suggests that effective change requires working with this natural resistance rather than fighting against it, primarily by building resources and alternative strategies before dismantling existing patterns. The concept brings together evolutionary psychology, systems theory, and somatic approaches to create a comprehensive understanding of why humans often remain stuck in problematic patterns despite conscious desires to change.

Graph View

Backlinks

  • No backlinks found